Tuesday, October 23, 2012

When the Killing (Mostly) Stopped - Reporters on 'The Troubles'


Soon, hopefully, 'The Troubles' will be a distant memory or history for the people of Britain and Ireland. But for almost thirty years, the slaughter or war or conflict or terrorism or whatever you wish to call it left thousands dead in Northern Ireland and probably destroyed interdenominational relations for at least two or three generations. 'The Troubles I've Seen' (UTV) interviews local Ulster Television reporters who covered that period (this is the second series, the first included bigger 'name' journalist like Trevor McDonald who cut their cloth in the 1970s and 80s). It brought back a lot of the distant, half-remembered atrocities and killings that 'thetvreviewguy' had forgotten. It must be a painful series for many to take part in and watch, where the reporters talk about the toll taken on their own resources; as one observed, 'there was no such thing as counselling in those days'. Anyone over 35 will have grown up with the, at time's daily death toll ringing on the News. The generation below 25 will barely remember the violence at all. What does remain is entrenched sectarianism, hatred and tribal allegiances. So much has changed though and many of these reporters could not have envisaged the Good Friday Agreement or Sinn Fein and the DUP sharing power. But the footage of Gordon Wilson after Enniskillen or the carnage of the Gibraltar spiral of violence serve as a reminder as to how dark things seemed at the time and how peace seemed little more than a pipe dream. An important series that reminds us of 'the hand of history'.

Trump - What a Joker.


'You've Been Trumped' (BBC2) was the sort of documentary that makes 'thetvreviewguy' angry. Anthony Baxter's film has already won plaudits from 'Local Hero' Director Bill Forsyth and the account of how Donald Trump has destroyed a beautiful, scenic site of special scientific interest near Aberdeen, Scotland, to build an exclusive golf course will make you angry too. Trump, never thought of as one of the World's 'Good Guys' comes out even worse than the common perception of him as we see how he see how this swaggering, money-obsessed, soi-disant Captain of Industry denigrates the local residents,  has his representatives cut off the local water supply of one of the protestors (presumably by accident, but shown to be tardy in making it good) and has a complete lack of self-awareness as the viewer sees a selfish tycoon wreak havoc on the local environment. Trump's bluster and crudeness are legendary; this is a man who made a complete fool of himself when running for President in 2011. This is a partly soul-destroying documentary in one-way; money talks and Trump's money or perception of unbridled wealth surely cows a lot of those wanting to oppose him and the activities of this loathsome man have never been better documented. Baxter is to be commended for putting this whole sorry affair on record; there may well be a deserved afterlife for 'You've Been Trumped' on-line. There will always be the likes of Donald Trump around and there will always be decent people not afraid to stand up to him. A great piece of film-making.

It's Not Brain Surgery (It Is Actually)


'Monroe', (ITV) a light-ish, medical drama starring James Nesbitt is very relaxing telly. Perfectly scheduled at 9pm  Monday (for that weary, first day back at work viewer), it won't challenge too much but this contrasts with putting the audience through an 'ER' wringer where the medical storylines got increasingly more bizarre or extreme. While 'thetvreviewguy' is no doctor, he does enjoy the medical mumbo-jumbo in this slightly sedate series along with the self-deprecating humour which Nesbitt is a natural at delivering. Now in its second series, 'Monroe' has a strong supporting cast and credits in particular must go to Neil Pearson (of 'Drop the Dead Donkey' fame) playing Monroe's much put-upon supervisor and younger cast members like the talented Michelle Asante. But it's Nesbitt who excels, coasting the 'regular bloke' stuff and convincing during the more stressful scenarios too. Neurosurgery is one of those 'wow' areas for most of us and 'Monroe' captures the emotions of patient and surgeon alike with a mostly light touch but sensitivity too. It hits all the slot formula requirements; a generally comforting post-return to work programme for a Monday night, with attendant humour, a little romance and story arcs that aren't too demanding. Particularly easygoing viewing, 'Monroe' hits the mark as autumn fare and confirms Nesbitt as the talented television character actor he is.

Mission Implausible


Oh Dear...'Strike Back - Vengeance' (SKY One) is a Chris Ryan SAS/Special Forces embarrassment of a programme that shows just how far Sky still have to go to make consistently decent stuff. Firstly, the dialogue, such as it is, is appalling and grossly insulting to the audience's intelligence; in one of the episodes, one of the characters asks of another 'Cui Bono?', to which the other cut-out instantly adds, for the benefit of us morons presumably, 'who benefits?'. 'Strike Back' operates in a universe where the only news channel on in the background is 'Sky News', where no cliche is left unused and where the explosions, shootings and fist fights add to the tedium of the proceedings. This isn't even switch the brain off TV, it made 'thetvreviewguy' want to switch the set off. The alpha male and female cast do their best with the ludicrous script and plot and Charles Dance must have been offered a large wodge of cash to appear in such nonsense. Of course there's a 'Ronseal' element to productions like this; no-one's expecting great innovation, wit or creativity and this won't disappoint. At least a Chris Ryan book will get you from one airport to another; 'Strike Back' just has 'thetvreviewguy' asking why they bothered. Watch this for a master class in bad drama and how not to write. Mission Fail.

Reconstructed Man


Dr Alice Roberts is a great find for the BBC - 'thetvreviewguy' has been a big fan of hers for years and she shines in the latest BBC2 Science venture, 'Prehistoric Autopsy', on five nights this week. Last night, together with Dr George McGavin and a team of scientists, specialists and other technicians, Roberts reconstructed a Neanderthal Man. It was a fascinating look at pre-history. Neanderthals, it turns out, shared many characteristics of Homo Sapiens, its one time rivals in the Human Race race. 'Ned' (as 'thetvreviewguy' is going to call him, without checking a search engine to see that this has been done before), enjoyed painting, both cave and primitive jewellery, probably used a basic form of language and also formed book clubs and met once a month for discussion (one of these statements isn't true). We know that 'Ned' may have had red hair and was an accomplished hunter, stabbing at the knees of large game to obtain food and skins for clothing. He was around only about 30,000 years ago which, in geological time, is a mere blink of an eye and it is both comforting and discomforting to think how close we are to are pre-historic ancestors. Drs Roberts and McGavin ably steered the viewer on this entertaining journey into the past, showing how serious television can be both an education and a joy to watch.